10+ local pizza joints + what to order

barley's pizza

Pizza from Barley’s

Pizza Perk: You don’t even need utensils to get in the way of your mouth and that cheesy delicious-ness.

And I won’t get in the way of you and your guide to Greenville’s local pizza joints:

Stone Pizza Company | 500 E Park Ave
What to order: The Neopolitan and some breadsticks

Swamp Pizza | Swamp Rabbit Cafe: 205 Cedar Lane Rd
What to order: The kale and sausage pizza

Sidewall Pizza

Sidewall Pizza

Sidewall Pizza | 3 locations in the Upstate
What to order: The Red and Green Basil Pesto pizza + The Arugula Salad.

Frodo’s Pizza | 511 S Pleasantburg Dr
What to order: The Everything with a Chocolate Chip Pizza for dessert.

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria | 1025 Woodruff Rd
What to order: The Don with extra sauce – it’s amazing.

Tony’s New York Style Pizzeria | 30 Orchard Park Dr
What to order: The Pepperoni Lovers and any flavor gelato.

Paisano’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant | 8590 Pelham Rd
What to order: Pepperoni pizza – the pepperonis are UNDER the cheese. (The salads aren’t bad either.)

D’Allesandro’s Pizza | 17 Mohawk Dr.
What to order: It’s Too Easy Being Green. It’s vegetarian – this place is great for veg heads.

slice from Vic's Pizza

Vic’s Pizza

Vic’s Pizza | 12 E Coffee St
What to order: The “5” Boroughs. If you are having a party, get the 28-inch Vic’s Bronx Bomber – the biggest pizza pie in Greenville.

Antonino Bertolo’s Pizza & Wine Bar | 200 N Main
What to order: The Buffalo Chicken. They also have a walk-up window open late night on the weekends (12 – 3 a.m.).

Sciortino’s Trattoria and Pizzeria | 3734 Pelham Rd
What to order: Grandma’s Pizza and also enjoy complimentary garlic knots

Mellow Mushroom | 1 Augusta St #201
What to order: The Thai Dye with a Kentucky Collins to drink.

There is literally no wrong time for pizza. It’s like everyone’s most reliable friend. So get out there and try them all – one at a time or all in one week – and share your favorite slices and spots with us using #GVLtoday.

P.S. There’s an app called Pizza Compass. You’re welcome.

– Jordan

More from GVLtoday
Sponsored
A local nonprofit gives new life to old pianos by teaming up with local artists across Greenville.
Greenville’s Design Review Board approved plans for a mixed-use development on the site of the former Municipal Court Building and the former American Legion building.
Here are 10 must-do activities for your Greenville spring bucket list that are unique to the Upstate and the spring season.
We’re putting our city’s vibrant ecosystem front-and-center in this new series.
Sponsored
Greenville is full of special places to stay that offer guests a break from traditional motels and hotels.
From upgraded suites to all-new menus around the ballpark, 2026 is all about celebrating the Upstate’s “Home Team.”
The road to the Final Four could start in Greenville, either for the Furman Paladins looking to shine their glass slippers or one of the teams starting the NCAA Tournament here for rounds one and two.
Grab a blanket and settle in to see these artists at local outdoor venues in Greenville.