A Greenville woman tried on Mom’s 1985 wedding dress — but it isn’t hers

It’s been 40 years since Connie Payne had her wedding dress preserved at a Greenville dry cleaner (that has since closed). When she pulled out the dress for her daughter to try on ahead of her 2026 wedding, it wasn’t her dress.

GVL_Wedding_Dress_Mixup_AUG2025

The dresses are so similar, it’s hard to tell at first glance. | Photos via Maggie Payne

Something (unintentionally) borrowed. Did you get married in Greenville late 1985 or early 1986? Did you have your dress cleaned or preserved at Mayhew Laboratories, Inc. on Bradshaw Street? If yes, keep scrolling. If no... still keep scrolling, because this is a good story.

Maggie Payne is getting married in March 2026, and like many brides do, she wants to pay homage to her mom by incorporating her dress into her big day. Mayhew Laboratories, a now-closed dry cleaner, had preserved it following her parents’ wedding in December 1985. It was then packed away for four decades, but when they recently pulled it out for Maggie to try on, it was someone else’s dress — not the one worn by Maggie’s mom, Connie, 40 years ago.

“I can see how the gowns may have gotten mixed up,” one TikTok user commented on Maggie’s video, which currently has 67,000 views. “They look so similar at first glance.”

GVL_Wedding_Dress_AUG2025

Plus, the veil in the box was not her mom’s veil — case closed. | Photos via Maggie Payne

We thought the same thing, but notice how the lace on the sleeves is different, along with the shape of the detail along the neckline.

There’s no way to follow up with Mayhew Laboratories because the Bradshaw Street business closed. It was founded in 1940 and specialized exclusively in cleaning wedding gowns. According to the founder’s obituary published in 1991, one of the dresses worn by movie star + Greenville High alumna Joanne Woodward in “Three Faces of Eve” (which earned her a Best Actress Oscar) was cleaned there.

What better way to reach 80,000+ Greenvillians to track down the dress than to slap this story at the very top of the GVLtoday newsletter, right? Let’s help Maggie and Connie get this dress back to its owner — and hopefully find theirs in the process.

More from GVLtoday
From a West Greenville High School update to plans to extend car rider loops, here’s what GCS wants to do.
Sponsored
Whether you’re participating in Record Store Day 2024 or you’re just looking to shop local for some music, we’ve rounded up record stores in Greenville, SC.
Each week, GVLtoday and CLTtoday will recap “Top Chef: Carolinas” with fun facts we’ve learned from our reporting behind the scenes and our pro tips about venues featured in each of our cities.
A new interior design and decor store aims to capture the essence of Greenville’s neighborhood with a new home fragrance line.
Sponsored
History, horticulture, and a hint of espionage — Travelers Rest is planting the seeds for an immersive new garden honoring Revolutionary War heroine Dicey Langston, with a fundraising dinner set to help bring the vision to life.
Starting May 1, the weekend trolley has new stops. Here’s what you need to know.
Pack your reusable shopping bags, because we’ve rounded up farmers markets around Greenville, SC.
This year, a record 89 events will take over Greenville, showcasing food, beverage, and music.